Skip to content

Known Before Birth, Yet “I Never Knew You”? Jeremiah 1:5 and Matthew 7:23

There are two statements in Scripture that can stop a reader in their tracks.

“Before I formed thee in the belly I knew thee; and before thou camest forth out of the womb I sanctified thee, and I ordained thee a prophet unto the nations.” — Jeremiah 1:5 (KJV)

“And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity.” — Matthew 7:23 (KJV)

In one passage, God says, “I knew thee.” In the other, Jesus says, “I never knew you.”

How do these statements fit together? If God knows everything, how can Jesus tell anyone that He never knew them?

The answer begins with something we should always do when studying the Bible: read each passage in its own context before connecting them.

1. Jeremiah 1:5: God Knew Jeremiah Before His Birth

Jeremiah 1 records the Lord calling Jeremiah to be a prophet. The opening of the chapter identifies Jeremiah, places him in Judah’s history, and introduces the word of the Lord that came to him.

God then tells Jeremiah that He knew him before he was formed in the womb, had set him apart, and had appointed him to be a prophet to the nations. Jeremiah responds by protesting that he does not know how to speak because he is young (Jeremiah 1:6). The Lord reassures him that He will be with him and will give him the words to speak (Jeremiah 1:7–9).

This is more than a general statement that God knows people exist. In this passage, the Lord speaks of His purpose and calling for Jeremiah before Jeremiah had begun his earthly life. The prophet’s authority comes from God’s appointment, not from Jeremiah’s own confidence or qualifications.

We should not turn Jeremiah’s particular calling into the claim that every person has been appointed a prophet, or that this verse by itself proves every person’s salvation. God is speaking specifically to Jeremiah about his prophetic ministry.

At the same time, other passages, such as Psalm 139:1–16, teach God’s intimate knowledge of human life. Jeremiah 1:5 vividly shows that God’s knowledge is not limited by the boundaries of our earthly timeline.

Read Jeremiah 1 in the Scripturestead Bible.

2. Matthew 7:23: A Warning at the End of the Sermon on the Mount

Now consider the setting of Jesus’ words. Matthew 7 comes at the conclusion of the Sermon on the Mount. Jesus warns about the narrow and broad ways (Matthew 7:13–14), false prophets and the fruit by which they are recognized (7:15–20), and the difference between merely hearing His words and actually living by them (7:24–27).

In the middle of these warnings, He says:

“Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven.” — Matthew 7:21 (KJV)

Jesus then describes people who appeal to impressive religious acts: prophesying, casting out devils, and performing wonderful works in His name (Matthew 7:22). Yet His response is devastating: “I never knew you.”

These people are not strangers to religious language. They call Jesus “Lord.” They point to what they believe they accomplished in His name. But Jesus exposes the terrible possibility of religious activity without genuine allegiance to Him.

Notice also the words that follow: “ye that work iniquity.” Their lives are characterized by lawlessness, even while they claim His name. The warning is about more than imperfect performance; it concerns a false profession that does not reflect submission to Christ.

Read Matthew 7 in the Scripturestead Bible.

3. What Does “I Never Knew You” Mean?

Jesus is not saying that He was unaware these people existed. That would contradict the Bible’s teaching that God knows the thoughts, actions, and hearts of human beings (see Psalm 139:1–4).

In Scripture, knowing someone can mean more than possessing information about that person. The word can also describe personal recognition, fellowship, and relationship. In Matthew 7:23, Jesus’ statement is a rejection of the claim that these people truly belonged to Him.

There is an important difference between knowing facts about Jesus and being known by Jesus as one of His own.

Jesus uses the language of relationship elsewhere. In John 10:14, He says, “I am the good shepherd, and know my sheep, and am known of mine.” In John 10:27, He adds, “My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me.”

Matthew 7:23 does not suggest that God sometimes forgets people. The words “I never knew you” express the absence of the genuine relationship those speakers claimed to have.

4. Are Jeremiah 1:5 and Matthew 7:23 Contradictory?

No. They are addressing different questions in different settings.

  • Jeremiah 1:5 speaks of God’s prior knowledge of Jeremiah and His specific appointment of him as a prophet.
  • Matthew 7:23 speaks of Jesus’ refusal to recognize certain professing followers as truly belonging to Him at judgment.

The first passage concerns God’s knowledge and calling. The second concerns authentic discipleship and relationship with Christ. The English word know appears in both, but its meaning must be understood from the context, not assumed to be identical in every verse.

God’s complete knowledge of a person is not the same claim as Jesus’ acknowledgment that a person belongs to Him. These two truths can stand together without contradiction.

5. Is Jesus Teaching Salvation by Good Works?

Matthew 7:21 speaks of doing the Father’s will, and the surrounding verses emphasize good fruit and obedience. It would be a mistake, however, to turn this into the idea that people can earn eternal life by accumulating enough impressive deeds.

In fact, those rejected in Matthew 7:22 are the ones pointing to their impressive deeds as their defense. Their résumé does not establish a relationship with Christ.

Ephesians 2:8–10 holds together two truths Christians must not separate: salvation is by grace through faith, not the result of works we can boast about; and those saved by God’s grace are created in Christ Jesus for good works.

Obedience does not purchase salvation. Rather, a life changed by Christ should bear fruit. That is why Jesus’ warning asks us to examine the reality of our faith, not merely the extent of our religious involvement.

There is a difference between a believer who stumbles, repents, and returns to Christ and a person who uses His name while remaining determined to disregard His authority. Jesus is not demanding a flawless record from people who need His grace. He is exposing empty profession.

6. The Question These Passages Place Before Us

It’s easy to read Matthew 7 and immediately think of someone else: a public preacher, a religious leader, or a person whose behavior troubles us. But Jesus’ warning should first invite an honest examination of our own hearts.

We can attend church, memorize verses, teach Bible studies, build ministries, and speak about God regularly. All of those activities can be good. None of them, by itself, is a substitute for trusting Christ, following Him, and responding to His Word.

We should ask not only, “How much do I know about God?” but also, “Am I truly trusting and following Jesus Christ?”

That question should lead us neither to pride in our accomplishments nor to despair over our weaknesses. It should lead us to Christ Himself—to faith, repentance, humility, obedience, and dependence on His grace.

Jeremiah 1 reminds us that God’s purposes are greater than our abilities. Matthew 7 reminds us that an outward appearance of faith is not the same as a heart that belongs to Christ.

The goal of knowing Scripture is not merely to collect knowledge about God. It is to respond to the God Scripture reveals.

Questions for Personal Study

  1. What was God specifically calling Jeremiah to do in Jeremiah 1:4–10?
  2. What kinds of claims do the people in Matthew 7:22 make about themselves?
  3. How do Matthew 7:15–27 and John 10:27 help explain the relationship between faith and obedience?
  4. What is the difference between relying on religious accomplishments and relying on Christ?
  5. How can we examine our hearts honestly while resting in God’s grace?

Closing Reflection

Two statements. Two settings. One serious invitation to study Scripture carefully.

God said to Jeremiah, “I knew thee.” Jesus warned some professing followers, “I never knew you.”

The question is not whether God has information about us. The question Matthew 7 presses upon us is whether our profession of faith reflects a real relationship with the Savior we claim to follow.

May we never mistake knowing the language of faith for knowing the Lord of our faith.

Rooted in Scripture. Standing in Truth.